Accent-Based Citizenship Checks Raise Profiling Concerns (Full Transcript)

A man recounts Border Patrol demanding proof of U.S. citizenship based on his accent and appearance after a fatal shooting, sparking outrage over profiling.
Download Transcript (DOCX)
Speakers
add Add new speaker

[00:00:00] Speaker 1: What do you mean if I'm from this country?

[00:00:01] Speaker 2: I can hear you don't have the same accent as me. That's why I'm asking you.

[00:00:03] Speaker 1: Oh, so you're going by accents now?

[00:00:05] Speaker 2: We just heard that that agent saying, I can hear you don't have the same accent as me. That's why I'm asking you, which I think is a pretty stunning thing to hear. I mean, then, so you're talking to them. You talk about the woman first, then there's him. And then, actually, Greg Bovino, right? The guy, the top guy at the time on the ground of all of this, shows up by your window. And you've shared some more of that exchange. Let me play it.

[00:00:31] Speaker 1: The big boss over here. What's going on? They're just harassing people based on skin color, man. Are we in Germany? No, no, no, come on. What do you guys want to do today? You guys want to take me in or something? Oh, that depends. Are you an illegal alien? Illegal alien? Man, yes. I might be from another planet. Okay, well, if that's the case, if you're from another planet, that counts, too. Well, if that counts, well, I'm an alien, guys. Let's do DNA tests and shit. You got a lab? We can run some blood tests, see what the hell I have. You guys shooting at people, man. Somebody just got shot. For what? Why did you guys shoot that lady? Answer me that. There's an officer today that shot a lady in the head, dude. Really? For what? I don't know why they do that, man. You got all this stuff. You could've just got her, man. She's not gonna fly out of the country. Like an alien. Like an alien. With a spaceship. With a spaceship. Yeah.

[00:01:19] Speaker 2: So, obviously, you sound confident there, Afmeh, but I can only imagine. Obviously, this is hours after Renee is shot and killed, and you're sitting there feeling that, guys already told you that because of your accent, you have to prove you're an American. Greg Bovino walks up. Did you feel scared a bit that things could go wrong?

[00:01:39] Speaker 1: I mean, it was very obvious to me by the way Border Patrol was acting with me unprofessionally that they really didn't care about my identity. There's something else other than what was obvious that was going on. So, when he said, you know what? I know you're not an American citizen, and I demand that you show me proof of that American citizenship verification, documents, whatever. I need that. What's making me ask you this stuff is, you do not sound like me. You don't have the same, and then he pointed to his face, you don't have the same accent as me. So, I was shocked. I was startled. I said, we're using accents now to verify citizenship? Are we using, it was just absurd to hear that, you know, for the first time in my life. I'm like, accents? Wow, there's so many different accents in America, right? There's the Spanish accent, there's the Italian accent, there's the Boston accent, there's the Texas accent, there's the Arkansas accent, which I'm not a big fan of. But then again, this guy chose to say, you gotta sound like me to be a US citizen. So, I was like, hey, I'm not gonna partake in this nonsense. What I'm gonna do now is, I'm gonna use the same energy he's using towards me on him.

ai AI Insights
Arow Summary
In a tense exchange after a woman named Renee is shot and killed, a man recounts being questioned by Border Patrol officers who suggest his accent and appearance indicate he may not be a U.S. citizen. A senior agent, Greg Bovino, allegedly demands proof of citizenship, citing that the man does not “sound like” him and referencing facial features. The man describes being shocked by the use of accent as a proxy for citizenship, calls it absurd given America’s diverse accents, and responds with sarcasm while expressing that the agents seemed unprofessional and unconcerned with his actual identity.
Arow Title
Border Patrol Questioning Based on Accent Sparks Outrage
Arow Keywords
Border Patrol Remove
accent discrimination Remove
citizenship verification Remove
racial profiling Remove
Greg Bovino Remove
use of force Remove
Renee shooting Remove
civil rights Remove
identity checks Remove
law enforcement conduct Remove
Arow Key Takeaways
  • Using accent or appearance as a proxy for citizenship raises serious concerns about profiling and civil rights violations.
  • The speaker describes officers as unprofessional and suggests their questioning was driven by motives beyond identity verification.
  • The incident occurs in the emotionally charged aftermath of a fatal police shooting, heightening fear and mistrust.
  • The exchange highlights the diversity of accents in the U.S. and the absurdity of equating one accent with citizenship.
  • Such encounters can intimidate citizens and non-citizens alike and erode public trust in border and law-enforcement agencies.
Arow Sentiments
Negative: The tone is tense and critical, emphasizing shock, fear, and outrage at perceived profiling and unprofessional conduct following a fatal shooting.
Arow Enter your query
{{ secondsToHumanTime(time) }}
Back
Forward
{{ Math.round(speed * 100) / 100 }}x
{{ secondsToHumanTime(duration) }}
close
New speaker
Add speaker
close
Edit speaker
Save changes
close
Share Transcript