Melania Documentary Claims: Ratings and Box Office Context (Full Transcript)

A fact-check of Melania Trump’s documentary performance, separating audience scores from critics and clarifying what ‘highest opening in a decade’ can mean.
Download Transcript (DOCX)
Speakers
add Add new speaker

[00:00:00] Speaker 1: Melania Trump has released her documentary. On Sunday she claimed it's the highest opening weekend for a documentary in a decade, with some high ratings too. But were these claims accurate? Spreadsheets out. Popcorn Meter, the online fan rating system, did give the movie 99%, but film website Rotten Tomatoes Critics' score was 10% on Sunday, not 98%, and the cinema score rating is an A. Other scoring websites such as Metacritic and IMDb had lower scores, and it may have the highest opening weekend box office in a decade, but only in the US market, not counting China. Melania has had a reported opening weekend of over $7 million, more than the expected estimate of $5 million. But the highest grossing opening weekend for a documentary is Justin Bieber's Never Say Never, which opened with $29 million in the US and Canada in 2011. And if we're counting concert films, then Bieber and Melania are dwarfed by Taylor Swift's Eras Tour, which opened with $93 million in 2023. So Melania has had the highest grossing opening of any documentary in the past 10 years in the US market, but not if you're including concert films.

ai AI Insights
Arow Summary
The segment fact-checks claims about Melania Trump’s documentary performance and ratings. It notes a 99% audience-style “Popcorn Meter” score but a much lower Rotten Tomatoes critics score (10% on Sunday), with other sites like Metacritic and IMDb also lower. Box office claims are partly true: the film reportedly opened above expectations at over $7M, which could make it the biggest U.S. documentary opening in the past decade, but not globally (China excluded) and not historically. Justin Bieber’s 2011 documentary opened far higher at $29M, and if concert films count, Taylor Swift’s 2023 Eras Tour dwarfs both with a $93M opening.
Arow Title
Fact-check: Melania Trump documentary ratings and box office claims
Arow Keywords
Melania Trump Remove
documentary Remove
box office Remove
opening weekend Remove
Rotten Tomatoes Remove
Popcorn Meter Remove
Metacritic Remove
IMDb Remove
CinemaScore Remove
Justin Bieber Never Say Never Remove
Taylor Swift Eras Tour Remove
fact-check Remove
Arow Key Takeaways
  • Audience-driven ratings showed very high approval, but critics’ ratings were much lower on Rotten Tomatoes at the time cited.
  • Reported opening weekend revenue exceeded forecasts (~$7M vs ~$5M expected).
  • The ‘highest opening in a decade’ claim may be accurate only for U.S. documentaries over the last 10 years and depends on definitions (excluding concert films and non-U.S. markets).
  • Historically, Justin Bieber’s 2011 documentary opened much higher, and concert films like Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour far surpass these figures.
Arow Sentiments
Neutral: The tone is analytical and corrective, focusing on verifying numerical claims about ratings and box office rather than expressing approval or disapproval.
Arow Enter your query
{{ secondsToHumanTime(time) }}
Back
Forward
{{ Math.round(speed * 100) / 100 }}x
{{ secondsToHumanTime(duration) }}
close
New speaker
Add speaker
close
Edit speaker
Save changes
close
Share Transcript